Romans 11:1-5 – Has God Cast Away His People?
As we come to Romans 11 in this episode, we have Paul beginning to address a slightly different question.
In Romans 9 and 10, he’s explained why Israel did not receive the promised kingdom blessings spoken of by the prophets. The issue wasn’t that God failed. The issue was that Israel stumbled at Christ.
When Christ came, God required faith.
“Speed Slider”
Romans 11:1-5 – Has God Cast Away His People? – Transcript
As we come to Romans 11 in this episode, we have Paul beginning to address a slightly different question.
In Romans 9 and 10, he’s explained why Israel did not receive the promised kingdom blessings spoken of by the prophets. The issue wasn’t that God failed. The issue was that Israel stumbled at Christ.
When Christ came, God required faith.
Israel had the Scriptures, the covenants, and the promises, but they were unwilling to trust that Jesus was the long-promised and prophesied Messiah, the Son of God. Instead of coming to God by faith, they tried to come by religious works. That’s where they stumbled.
Paul summarises the principle in Romans 10:17:
“Faith cometh by hearing, and hearing by the word of God.”
Just possessing God’s Word wasn’t enough.
They had to believe it. And because God saves through faith, Israel’s unbelief left them without excuse.
At the end of Romans 10, Paul quotes both Isaiah and Hosea, showing that this wasn’t some new problem.
The Old Testament prophets had already described Israel as a disobedient and unbelieving people. Romans 10:21 says, God speaking,
“All day long I have stretched forth my hands unto a disobedient and gainsaying people.”
Gainsaying describes openly resisting and arguing against God. Stubbornly rejecting what God says. They weren’t just ignoring God; they were arguing with Him and resisting His call.
That’s a sobering picture.
God was reaching out, but Israel was resisting. They stood in opposition to the very God who was calling them.
Naturally, this raises a question.
If Israel rejected Christ, if they are fallen and faithless, does that mean God’s finished with them forever?
Paul asks that exact question in Romans 11:1:
“Hath God cast away his people?”
To answer it, we need to remember what the prophets actually said.
Think about Hosea.
God warned the northern tribes that because of their rebellion, they’d lose their land, their king, and their privileges. But judgment was never the whole story. Alongside the warnings were promises of restoration.
In Hosea 6:1, Israel says,
“Come, and let us return unto the Lord: for he hath torn, and he will heal us.”
The God who disciplines is also the God who restores. The same hand that chastens is the hand that heals.
Then in Hosea 14, God calls Israel to return.
He tells them to come with words of repentance and faith, saying,
“Take away all iniquity, and receive us graciously.”
Notice that. Their hope wasn’t in works. Their hope was in God’s grace. They knew they had iniquity, and only God could take that away by His grace.
And God’s response is remarkable:
“I will heal their backsliding, I will love them freely.”
He promises restoration, blessing, growth, and prosperity. Israel would flourish like an olive tree.
That’s important because it shows that the same prophets who foretold Israel’s fall also foretold Israel’s return.
This is a truth we must not miss.
Sometimes people think grace only appears in the present dispensation. But God’s always been gracious. The prophets spoke of Israel being restored by God’s grace long before Paul wrote Romans.
So when we arrive at Romans 11, we should already know the answer to this question of “Hath God cast away his people?” Israel’s present unbelief is real. Their fall is real. Their judgment is real. But God’s promises are real too.
The same Scriptures that predicted their disobedience also predicted their restoration.
“Hath God cast away his people?” Has God permanently abandoned Israel? Is their rejection final?
Paul’s answer, which unfolds through Romans 11, is a resounding no.
Israel has stumbled, but God’s not finished with them. The God who promised judgment also promised restoration, and He will remain faithful to every promise He has made.
As we begin Romans 11, Paul answers this natural question that comes from everything he’s been teaching in Romans 9 and 10. If Israel rejected their Messiah, if they stumbled at Christ, if they refused to believe, then has God permanently rejected them?
Many people would answer yes.
They would say that because Israel rejected and crucified Christ, God is finished with them and has replaced them with the Church. But Paul’s answer is immediate and unmistakable in Romans 11:1:
“I say then, Hath God cast away his people? God forbid.”
That answer should settle the whole thing. Paul’s just spent Romans 10 describing Israel’s unbelief, yet when he reaches Romans 11, he doesn’t conclude that God’s done with Israel. Instead, he declares the exact opposite.
This chapter is about the future restoration of Israel, and it’s important to keep that main point in view.
Later we’ll encounter difficult passages about the olive tree and the branches, and it’s easy to get lost in the details. But we shouldn’t miss the big picture. Paul’s purpose is to show that although Israel has fallen, Israel has not been permanently cast away. God will still fulfil the covenant promises He made to them.
Romans 11 is about Israel’s future fullness, future restoration, and future salvation.
So in Romans 11:1 Paul asks the question and then immediately begins presenting evidence.
He says:
“I SAY then, Hath God cast away his people? God forbid. For I also am an Israelite, of the seed of Abraham, of the tribe of Benjamin.”
Paul’s first proof is himself.
Why is that significant?
Because if God had truly cast away Israel forever, then Paul could not have received mercy.
Paul was an Israelite.
He belonged to the seed of Abraham. He knew exactly which tribe he came from. He wasn’t merely claiming Jewish heritage; he could trace his lineage to Benjamin.
Paul’s saying, in effect, “Look at me. I’m an Israelite, and God has shown me mercy.”
That’s powerful because Paul certainly wasn’t seeking God’s favour when Christ stopped him on the Damascus road. In fact, he was resisting Christ and persecuting believers. Yet God saved him.
So Paul himself stands as evidence that God has not abandoned Israel.
Notice something important here. Paul doesn’t say God cast away Israel and replaced them with the Church. Neither does he say that the Church is now the fulfilment of Israel’s promises.
Some people read the verse that way.
They see Paul as a member of the Body of Christ and conclude that Israel’s promises are now being fulfilled spiritually in the Church. But that’s not Paul’s argument.
Paul doesn’t say, “Look at me, I’m in the Body of Christ.”
He says, “I also am an Israelite.”
He’s speaking about his physical identity as an Israelite because the question concerns Israel.
His point is simple: God has not cast away His people because an Israelite is standing there as living evidence of God’s mercy.
Who knew more about that mercy than Paul?
Before he was saved, he was convinced he was serving God. He was zealous for the law. He was advancing in Judaism. He said he was blameless concerning the righteousness found in the law. Yet he was completely ignorant of God’s righteousness revealed in Christ.
Romans 10:3 describes Israel as those who were:
“Going about to establish their own righteousness.”
And Paul could definitely say, “I’ve been there. That was me.”
When Romans 10:21 speaks of a “disobedient and gainsaying people,” Paul knew firsthand what that looked like because he had been one of them. He opposed Christ. He persecuted believers. He fought against what God was doing.
And yet God saved him.
Remember, in Romans 10, Paul spoke of Israel as his “kinsmen” and testified that they had a zeal for God but not according to knowledge.
Paul knew exactly how they thought because he’d once stood among them in that same unbelief.
The difference now is that Paul has believed Christ.
He has received the righteousness of God by faith. Many of his fellow Israelites have not.
So Paul’s argument is simple. You can’t read Romans 10 and conclude that God is done with Israel because Paul himself was once part of that unbelieving nation and is now a recipient of God’s grace.
Now Paul isn’t in any way saying he’s the fulfilment of Israel’s promises.
He’s not claiming that the Body of Christ replaces Israel or inherits Israel’s covenants. That’s not his point.
His point is much simpler:
“God saved me, an Israelite. Therefore God has not cast away Israel.”
Paul’s salvation demonstrates that Israelites can still be received by God.
The question then becomes: How was Paul saved?
It was not through Christ’s earthly ministry.
It was not through Peter’s ministry at Pentecost.
In fact, Paul was actively resisting those ministries. He was persecuting those who believed the message preached by Peter and the apostles.
Paul was saved when the risen Christ personally appeared to him.
In 1 Corinthians 15:8, Paul writes:
“Last of all he was seen of me also, as of one born out of due time.”
That phrase, “out of due time,” is important.
In prophecy, Israel’s salvation occurs when Christ returns to establish the kingdom. Romans 11 will later describe that future day when “all Israel shall be saved.”
But Paul experienced something unusual. Christ appeared to him before that appointed time. While Israel as a nation remained in unbelief, Paul was saved by grace through faith through a direct appearance of the risen Lord.
In that sense, Paul became a living demonstration of God’s mercy toward Israel.
Think about where this happened.
Israel had rejected Christ. Stephen had been stoned. Saul himself was leading the persecution against believers.
If there was ever a moment when someone might expect God to pour out judgment, this was it.
Instead, Christ appeared and saved Saul, and he began using his Roman name, Paul; Saul was his Hebrew name.
The first words from heaven were not words of destruction but words of conviction and mercy:
“Why persecutest thou me?”
Israel had rejected Christ, but Christ had not rejected Israel.
Even on the cross, Jesus prayed:
“Father, forgive them; for they know not what they do.”
That’s the heart behind Romans 11.
Israel’s rejection of their Messiah was not God’s final word concerning them. God’s promises still stand. His covenants remain secure. Their present unbelief does not cancel His future purpose.
Paul stands as the evidence.
A former persecutor.
A former unbeliever.
A former “disobedient and gainsaying” Israelite.
Now saved by grace.
And through his own conversion, Paul’s saying to Israel, “God has not cast you away. If He could save me, His promises to you are still certain.”
What’s even more remarkable is that Paul wasn’t searching for Christ when he got saved. He wasn’t repenting at Pentecost. He wasn’t among the thousands who heard Peter preach and responded in faith. He was actively opposing Christ and persecuting Christ’s followers.
Yet Christ came looking for him.
That’s an amazing testimony of grace.
That’s the great encouragement at the beginning of Romans 11.
God’s faithfulness is greater than Israel’s failure, and the God who showed mercy to Paul will one day fulfil every promise He made to His people.
Now that doesn’t mean Paul represents the fulfilment of Israel’s promised salvation.
Romans 11 is not teaching that Israel becomes the Church or that the Church becomes Israel. In fact, one of the great truths of the mystery that Christ later revealed to Paul is that today salvation is available apart from Israel’s national program. In the Body of Christ, there is neither Jew nor Gentile.
Paul’s salvation and Israel’s future salvation are related, but they’re not the same thing.
Paul was one Israelite saved by grace through faith.
Romans 11 is talking about the future salvation of the nation.
Paul’s conversion simply proves that God has not cast them away.
In Romans 11:2 Paul continues first with:
“God hath not cast away his people which he foreknew.”
The people foreknown here are the nation of Israel.
God chose Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob. He formed a nation and gave that nation promises, covenants, and a kingdom destiny. Long before Israel existed as a nation, God had purposed blessing through them.
That’s what Paul is talking about when he says God foreknew them.
God has not forgotten the nation He chose. He has not abandoned the promises He made. Israel’s present unbelief cannot cancel God’s faithfulness.
We’ve already seen this in Romans 9.
From the nation of Israel came two kinds of vessels: vessels of wrath and vessels of mercy. The difference was faith. Those who believed received mercy. Those who rejected God remained under judgment.
The issue was never nationality alone. The issue was faith.
Paul then continues in Romans 11:2 by asking:
“Wot ye not what the scripture saith of Elias?”
In other words, “Don’t you know what the Scriptures say about Elijah?”
It’s significant that Paul turns to Elijah.
He’s showing that Israel’s current situation isn’t something new. The pattern was already found in Israel’s history.
Paul then gives the reason he refers to Elijah in the rest of Romans 11:2 and into Romans 11:3;
“Wot ye not what the scripture saith of Elias? how he maketh intercession to God against Israel, saying,
Lord, they have killed thy prophets, and digged down thine altars; and I am left alone, and they seek my life.”
Elijah ministered during one of Israel’s darkest periods.
The nation had largely turned away from God. Ahab and Jezebel led Israel into idolatry, and false prophets filled the land.
Even after God’s dramatic victory on Mount Carmel, where fire fell from heaven and proved that the Lord was the true God, the nation’s leaders still rejected God’s prophet.
Instead of welcoming Elijah, they sought to kill him.
That sounds very familiar, doesn’t it?
Just as Israel rejected Elijah’s testimony, they later rejected Christ. Yet in Elijah’s day, God had not abandoned Israel. There was still a faithful remnant, and God still had future plans for His people.
In 1 Kings 19, Elijah has just stood for God against hundreds of false prophets on Mount Carmel.
God answered by fire from heaven. You’d think the nation would repent. You’d think Israel would finally return to the Lord.
Instead, Israel rejected God’s word, rejected God’s prophet, and sought to kill him.
So Elijah flees into the wilderness and cries out to God 1 Kings 19:14:
“I have been very jealous for the Lord God of hosts: because the children of Israel have forsaken thy covenant, thrown down thine altars, and slain thy prophets with the sword.”
When Paul refers to this passage in Romans 11:2-3, he gives us inspired commentary. He says Elijah was making intercession against Israel.
In other words, Elijah wasn’t just venting his frustrations. He was bringing a true charge against the nation, and everything he said was right. Israel had broken the covenant. They had rejected God’s prophets. Now they were trying to kill Elijah too.
Those are serious accusations.
And if God had responded strictly according to judgment, Elijah could’ve expected fire to fall again. After all, covenant-breaking deserved wrath.
But that’s not what happened.
Paul refers to Elijah crying out to god that he’s all alone. In Romans 11:3 we see him crying out,
“Lord, they have killed thy prophets, and digged down thine altars; and I am left alone, and they seek my life.”
God’s response is remarkable, Romans 11:4:
“But what saith the answer of God unto him? I have reserved to myself seven thousand men, who have not bowed the knee to the image of Baal.”
Instead of immediately judging the nation, God points Elijah to a remnant.
A small remnant, yes.
Seven thousand wasn’t much compared to the whole nation. But it was enough to demonstrate that God wasn’t finished with Israel.
Think about how closely this parallels the ministry of Christ.
When Jesus came, the nation largely rejected Him. Just like Israel rejected Elijah, they rejected God’s Son. They rejected His message, opposed His ministry, and ultimately sought His life.
Elijah said they had forsaken God’s covenant, rejected His prophets, and were seeking his life.
Jesus could’ve made the same claims.
The nation rejected John the Baptist. They rejected the prophets. They rejected their Messiah.
Yet what did Jesus do?
In John 17, instead of calling for judgment, He prayed for those who believed.
He said in John 17:6:
“I have manifested thy name unto the men which thou gavest me out of the world.”
Notice the difference.
Elijah looked at a rebellious nation and saw a people deserving judgment.
Jesus looked at a rebellious nation and saw a believing remnant through whom God would continue His work.
Again and again throughout John 17, Jesus prays for those disciples. He asks the Father to keep them, preserve them, and protect them.
Why?
Because they were the faithful remnant.
Just as God had a remnant of seven thousand that remained faithful to Him in Elijah’s day, Christ had His little flock in His day.
In fact, Jesus told them in Luke 12:32:
“Fear not, little flock; for it is your Father’s good pleasure to give you the kingdom.”
The kingdom belonged to those who believed. Those who believed were the little flock, the Remnant.
Not because they were better people, but because they responded in faith.
That has been the issue all through Romans 9, 10, and 11.
Those without faith missed the blessing, while those with faith received it.
But here’s the important point: those without faith were not beyond hope.
God did not immediately destroy the nation after they crucified Christ. Instead, He poured out the Holy Ghost on the believing remnant at Pentecost.
And what did that remnant do?
They turned right around and preached to the very nation that had rejected Christ.
They preached “Repent.” “Believe.” “Receive your Messiah.”
What an amazing display of God’s patience and grace.
The fact that Israel killed their Messiah was not God’s final word to Israel.
There was still an opportunity to believe.
There was still an invitation to repent.
There was still a promise waiting to be fulfilled.
That’s exactly Paul’s point in Romans 11. God has not cast away His people.
Israel’s unbelief could not cancel God’s faithfulness.
And the same God who withheld judgment in Elijah’s day, who extended mercy after the cross, and who continues to offer grace, is the God who will one day bring Israel into the salvation He promised long ago.
God isn’t finished with Israel because God’s promises don’t fail. Where there’s faith, there’s mercy. And where God has made a promise, He will keep it.
After God told Elijah about the seven thousand, He began identifying key individuals within that remnant. He sent Elijah to call Elisha. He raised up Jehu. He began working through a small group of faithful people.
Then Elijah was taken into heaven.
Sound familiar?
Christ ascended into heaven as well. And after His departure, He left behind a believing remnant to continue His work.
In both cases, God wasn’t abandoning Israel. He was working through a faithful remnant to accomplish His purposes.
Look at what eventually happened in Elijah’s story.
Years later, through the ministry that God established, Jehu rose to power and removed the house of Ahab. He destroyed Baal worship throughout the land.
2 Kings 10:28 says:
“Thus Jehu destroyed Baal out of Israel.”
Think about how remarkable that is.
Back in 1 Kings 19, Elijah felt completely defeated. Baal worship seemed unstoppable. Yet God was already at work through a remnant that would eventually restore the nation.
Elijah saw only the problem, but God saw the solution.
Paul wants us to see the same pattern in Romans 11.
When Jesus came, He gathered a believing remnant. At first, it was a very small group.
By Acts 1:15, there were about 120 gathered together. Then at Pentecost, about 3,000 were added, as Acts 2:41 shows. By Acts 4:4, the number had grown to about 5,000, still small compared to the nation as a whole, but God has never needed a majority to accomplish His purpose.
Like the seven thousand in Elijah’s day, this remnant stood in the midst of an unbelieving nation and preached God’s truth.
Peter boldly declared to the rulers of Israel in Acts 4:10:
“Jesus Christ of Nazareth, whom ye crucified, whom God raised from the dead.”
And then he added in Acts 4:12:
“Neither is there salvation in any other.”
What confidence! What boldness!
Why? Because they knew they represented God’s believing remnant.
The purpose of this remnant was not to condemn Israel but to call Israel back to faith. They were God’s gracious appeal to a nation that had stumbled.
God’s response to Israel’s failure was not immediate destruction. It was mercy. It was patience. It was the preservation of a remnant through whom He continued to offer salvation.
In Elijah’s day, He preserved a remnant. In Christ’s day, He preserved a remnant. And in the future, He will fulfil every promise He has made to Israel, and it’ll be the remnant that’ll receive them.
What looked hopeless to Elijah wasn’t hopeless to God.
And what looked like the end of Israel in Paul’s day wasn’t the end either.
God still had a remnant. God still had a purpose. And God was still extending grace.
This is why Paul says in Romans 11:5:
“Even so then at this present time also there is a remnant according to the election of grace.”
Notice those words, “even so.”
Paul’s saying, “Just as it was in Elijah’s day, so it is now.”
The believing remnant in Paul’s day parallels the believing remnant in Elijah’s day.
And that’s important because Paul isn’t introducing the mystery kept secret since the world began here as he does later. He’s explaining something the prophets had already spoken about. The preservation of a believing remnant was part of Israel’s prophetic program all along.
At the time Paul wrote Romans, unbelieving Israel was still rejecting the message. Yet Peter, James, John, and the believing remnant were still there, faithfully preaching Christ.
Paul knew that a remnant existed. In fact, before his conversion, he’d zealously persecuted them.
He’d been part of the opposition. He’d watched them suffer.
Yet instead of receiving judgment himself, he received grace.
That’s why Paul understands this subject so clearly.
He’d seen firsthand that God was not finished with Israel.
The lesson is simple: what looked hopeless to Elijah wasn’t hopeless to God, and what looked like the end of Israel wasn’t the end either.
God still had a remnant, and He was still extending grace.
And God was still moving toward the fulfilment of every promise He’d made to His people.
The faithful remnant was proof that Israel’s story wasn’t over. And for Paul, that remnant was evidence that God’s faithfulness was still at work, even in the midst of national unbelief.
Now when we hear the word remnant, we need to understand what it means. A remnant is what’s left of something that already exists. It’s a portion of a larger whole.
If you bake a cake and only a slice remains after it’s served, that slice is the remnant. It’s still part of the same cake. It’s not something entirely different. Israel is the cake, the remnant is the believing minority of Israel. It’s not a new entity. It’s not the Body of Christ. It’s believing Israel within the larger nation of Israel.
Many people read Romans 11 and immediately place the Church into the passage. But Paul’s subject isn’t the Body of Christ. His subject is Israel. The remnant is Israel that believes, just as there was a believing remnant in Elijah’s day.
The Body of Christ is different.
Paul calls it a new creature and a new man. It’s not a remnant of anything. It isn’t the leftover portion of Israel. In the Body of Christ, there’s neither Jew nor Gentile. It’s something entirely new. And also, when a person becomes a member of the Body of Christ through faith in the gospel of grace, he’s sealed by the Holy Spirit. No one leaves that body.
We see this in 2 Corinthians 1:21-22;
“Now he which stablisheth us with you in Christ, and hath anointed us, is God;
Who hath also sealed us, and given the earnest of the Spirit in our hearts.”
And Ephesians 1:13-14;
“In whom [thst’s Christ] ye also trusted, after that ye heard the word of truth, the gospel of your salvation: in whom also after that ye believed, ye were sealed with that holy Spirit of promise, which is the earnest [the guarantee] of our inheritance….”
And again in Ephesians 4:30;
“And grieve not the holy Spirit of God, whereby ye are sealed unto the day of redemption.”
The Body of Christ is complete and sealed. There cannot possibly be a remnant of the Body of Christ.
The remnant Paul is describing here isn’t new.
It existed before Paul’s conversion. In fact, John the Baptist began identifying that remnant before Christ’s earthly ministry even started.
In Luke 1:16-17, the Angel said this regarding John:
“Many of the children of Israel shall he [John] turn to the Lord their God. And he shall go before him in the spirit and power of Elias.”
John came in the spirit and power of Elijah.
Why? To prepare a people for the Lord. Just as Elijah stood in the midst of an unbelieving nation and God preserved a faithful remnant, John came to identify a believing remnant in Israel that would receive Christ.
John pointed people to Jesus then Jesus gathered that believing flock.
And after Christ’s rejection and ascension, that remnant continued preaching to Israel.
So when Paul says there’s a remnant at “this present time,” he’s talking about that believing Jewish remnant represented by Peter, James, John, and the thousands in Jerusalem who believed Jesus was the Christ.
This remnant existed because of God’s grace.
Notice Paul’s wording carefully in Romans 11:5:
“A remnant according to the election of grace.”
He doesn’t say according to the mystery. He doesn’t say according to the Body of Christ. He says according to grace.
That shouldn’t surprise us. God was gracious in Elijah’s day. Instead of destroying the nation, He preserved a remnant.
And God was gracious in Christ’s day. Instead of immediately judging Israel after they crucified their Messiah, He sent apostles to preach repentance and forgiveness.
Grace didn’t begin with Paul. God’s always been gracious.
Look at Peter’s preaching in Acts 2.
He stands before Israel and boldly declares:
“God hath made that same Jesus, whom ye have crucified, both Lord and Christ.”
Imagine hearing that.
The nation had rejected and crucified its Messiah. If anyone deserved judgment, it was them.
But instead of immediate wrath, Peter offers them an opportunity to repent.
Peter stood before Israel and said in Acts 2:38:
“Repent, and be baptized in the name of Jesus Christ for the remission of sins… and ye shall receive the gift of the Holy Ghost”.
Even after Israel had rejected and crucified their Messiah, God did not immediately pour out judgment. Instead, He extended grace. Through the believing remnant, Peter offered Israel another opportunity to believe.
Peter’s message was clear. In Acts 2:40, he preached:
“Save yourselves from this untoward generation”.
Like Elijah confronting a corrupt Israel in the days of Ahab and Jezebel, Peter was calling people to separate themselves from a nation living in unbelief. The kingdom had not yet come, and all Israel had not yet been saved, but God was still offering mercy through a faithful remnant.
That’s grace.
The remnant became God’s means of extending that grace to the nation.
And the presence of that believing remnant was evidence that God’s promises to Israel were still standing and that He was not finished with His people.
Through the believing remnant, God was still calling Israel to faith, still offering mercy, and still moving forward with His prophesied purpose.
Just as He preserved a faithful remnant through Elijah, He preserved a faithful remnant in the days of Christ and the apostles.
Israel’s unbelief was real.
Israel’s rejection of Christ was real.
But God’s grace was real too.
The lesson running through Romans 10 and 11 is simple: God requires faith. Israel stumbled because they would not believe. Yet God’s grace remained available to those who would turn to Him in faith. The same God who preserved a remnant then will one day fulfil every promise He made to Israel.
Unbelief brought loss, but faith receives grace.
That’s the heart of Romans 11.
May God bless you with the understanding of how faith is the key to God’s promises.






Leave a Reply
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!